PILLAR 03 · EXPERT INSIGHTS Interview EP 114

Self-Managing vs. Hiring a Property Manager in Ontario | Streetwise Wealth

with Elizabeth Kelly , Real Estate Investor, Operator, and Strategic Adviser , Sandstone Property Management / ekconsulting.ca
Play: Self-Managing vs. Hiring a Property Manager in Ontario | Streetwise Wealth
LISTEN ON ▶ YouTube
37 min · July 28, 2026 · 0 views
WHAT YOU'LL LEARN
  1. How to use deal economics to decide between self-management and professional management.
  2. The hidden costs of self-management, including legal risks and time trade-offs.
  3. Effective ways to screen property managers beyond Google reviews.
  4. Key questions to ask during the property management interview process.
  5. Red flags to watch for in property management agreements.
  6. How property management decisions impact Net Operating Income and property appraisal.
  7. The importance of treating tenants as clients to ensure long-term profitability.
Show Notes
Timestamps 8
Questions Answered 4
Mentioned In This Episode 2
Every rental property owner faces a management decision: manage it yourself or delegate to a professional. This choice isn't just about convenience; it's a critical business decision that directly impacts your Net Operating Income (NOI), property value, and future financing capacity.



In this episode, Dalia Barsoum sits down with Elizabeth Kelly, a veteran investor and co-founder of Sandstone Property Management. Elizabeth shares her dual perspective as both an investor and a manager, offering a deep dive into the decision framework, screening property managers, and avoiding costly legal mistakes in Ontario.
Should I manage my own rental property if it's close to me?

No, the decision should be based on deal economics rather than geographical distance. If the numbers don't support a management fee, the deal itself may be too slim.

What is the best way to find a reliable property manager?

While Google reviews can be helpful, Elizabeth recommends seeking referrals and word-of-mouth from other experienced investors in your local market or meetup groups.

What is a critical question to ask a potential property manager?

Instead of just asking 'how much do you charge?', ask 'what does your fee cover?' to understand the level of service and processes included.

How does property management affect my mortgage?

Operational efficiency, such as maintaining low vacancy and high rents, impacts your Net Operating Income (NOI), which directly affects your property's appraised value and mortgage qualification.

  • Streetwise Wealth Vault (Property Management Decision Guide)
  • ekconsulting.ca
Where do you start?